Tom Fitzpatrick

as John Mulaney

as Ignatius

as Mr. Cradley

as Ignatius

as Older Man

as Shopkeeper

as The Corpse

as Lawrence

as Elder John Bowers

as Questioner 2

as James

as Priest

as Mr. White

as Patient with Severe Burps

as Attendee #1

as Self

as Bride in Black

as Sigmund

as Mr. Able

as Dr. Schiff

as Bride in Black / Parker Crane (old)

as Mr. Bender

as Carl Langer

as Old Man McCue

as Richard Braddock

as Walter Sokoloff

as Coma Patient

as Jim

as Old Darrell

as Back Room Denizen

as Mr. Treadwell

as Crazy Old Man

as Gandalf

as Walter Beck

as Karaoke Man

as Caesar

as Older Man

as Jeremiah

as Eurydice (Dora Lee)/Travel Agent

as The 'John' in the Subway (uncredited)

as Eyeless Man

as Old Woman / Man

as Ray (as Roger Harkenrider)

as Self (as Roger Harkenrider)