Jimmy Bennett

as Andrew Holmes

as Jimmy

as Dustin

as Brian Slater

as Ronald

as Mojo

as Kevin

as Braden

as Alfie Rentman

as Fanglorious Bandmate

as Nathan (segment "Middleschool Date")

as Alex Willingham

as Ralph Gullivan

as J.J. Powell

as Bones White

as Moon Blake

as John

as Toby Thompson

as Daniel

as Young James T. Kirk

as Dillon

as Peter

as Buddha (voice)

as Ryan Baxter

as Rerun (voice)

as Young Pi (voice)

as Conor James

as Andy Stanfield

as Roo (voice)

as Michael Lutz

as Tommy Smith

as Lonely Boy (voice)

as Young Jeremiah

as Roo (voice)

as Rerun Van Pelt (voice)

as "The Flash" / Tony

as Self

as Sam Feeney

as Matty Butler

as Henry Turner

as Macon

as Willy

as Cory Sinkler